It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
orcishgamer: Please tell me your entire argument doesn't hinge on "breaking the law == wrong". That is provably false. Laws, of themselves, carry no morality.
avatar
Runehamster: No, it doesn't. My argument hinges on the fact that games == entertainment but games =/= necessity. I would never presume to tell someone that killing to defend themselves or stealing food so their children could eat is wrong. But breaking a law to get something you enjoy is inherently amoral. Not necessarily immoral, but amoral.
If it's amoral then it carries no moral consequence one way or the other and cannot be considered right or wrong.

I don't know why some people pirate, I don't care. There's clearly an issue with the social design if it is happening so often.

Also, just because it's not food, clothing or shelter doesn't mean people don't need it or want it (and sometimes for reasons that may surprise you). You'll damn well live if you break your arm and get it set at the hospital with no painkiller but the painkiller sure makes life nicer. I suspect when media companies become more reasonable with the public, most of the public will, in turn, become more reasonable. Even some game developers feel this way, please read Jeff Vogel's blog, he seems to be a really cool guy.

http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/07/sometimes-its-ok-to-steal-my-games.html
Does this really need to go on? It's just going to be a back and forth between two opposing sides, and nobody will ever be swayed and there will be bad blood because the OP started off being kinda... prickish? Can I say that here? And everybody responded by being prickish in turn and it's not going to enrich the forums at all with all this bickering.
avatar
doccarnby: Does this really need to go on? It's just going to be a back and forth between two opposing sides, and nobody will ever be swayed and there will be bad blood because the OP started off being kinda... prickish? Can I say that here? And everybody responded by being prickish in turn and it's not going to enrich the forums at all with all this bickering.
Eh, this argument happens every week like clockwork on these forums. You're right, it never goes anywhere, but it's sort of the "national pastime" if you will.
avatar
Runehamster: And on a side note, my analogy was perfect. I am well aware that test driving a car does NOT give you access to the full thing - you can't discover road mileage, you can't see how long it takes you to get to Grandma's, you don't have time to realize that the seat gives you a backache. Stealing a car would permit you to do these things, but it doesn't change the fact that you just committed a felony.
avatar
orcishgamer: Okay, I know you're trying to make a point, but seriously, you need to get away from the whole physical property examples, they don't work.

Also, legality and morality don't always match. So be careful there. In fact some laws make no sense whatsoever. Some do but are flawed, how long have people been trying to legalize pot in the US? Lobbying for change, even by large numbers of people, doesn't always work. In fact, sometimes the situation just continues to deteriorate. And I like the pot example, because in the 20s the US threw a fit about alcohol being made illegal and guess what, it's legal again.

Also, I like Jeff Vogel's take on piracy. Btw, I don't pirate cause I can afford not to and I'm lazy, that doesn't mean there aren't people who aren't easting saltines for the last two weeks of every month. http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/07/sometimes-its-ok-to-steal-my-games.html
I am sorry, I enjoy the physical parallels and have not yet heard a convincing argument to differentiate digital theft from physical theft. So if you wish to converse, you'll have to put up with them, I'm afraid, even if you disagree with them.

Legality and morality do not equate. This is true. If a law tells me to perform an act that I find morally reprehensible, I will refuse peacefully. This is known as civil disobedience. If a law tells me that I cannot perform an act that breaks the law for personal gain, this is called a crime.
avatar
orcishgamer: Eh, this argument happens every week like clockwork on these forums. You're right, it never goes anywhere, but it's sort of the "national pastime" if you will.
I have to say, that kinda makes me sad. With the exception of these threads, this has been the most serene, calming and tight-knit community I have ever been a part of.
avatar
doccarnby: I have to say, that kinda makes me sad. With the exception of these threads, this has been the most serene, calming and tight-knit community I have ever been a part of.
Aren't you glad it's only isolated in these threads? It's like we suddenly turn into different people in threads like these.

But this is pretty much like any other issue involving morality and a sense of what's right and wrong (e.g. religion). It's just a grey area that can be argued for either way, and that's what's happening. Both sides are sticking to their guns and trying to advance their position like some sort of static trench warfare.
avatar
orcishgamer: Okay, I know you're trying to make a point, but seriously, you need to get away from the whole physical property examples, they don't work.

Also, legality and morality don't always match. So be careful there. In fact some laws make no sense whatsoever. Some do but are flawed, how long have people been trying to legalize pot in the US? Lobbying for change, even by large numbers of people, doesn't always work. In fact, sometimes the situation just continues to deteriorate. And I like the pot example, because in the 20s the US threw a fit about alcohol being made illegal and guess what, it's legal again.

Also, I like Jeff Vogel's take on piracy. Btw, I don't pirate cause I can afford not to and I'm lazy, that doesn't mean there aren't people who aren't easting saltines for the last two weeks of every month. http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/07/sometimes-its-ok-to-steal-my-games.html
avatar
Runehamster: I am sorry, I enjoy the physical parallels and have not yet heard a convincing argument to differentiate digital theft from physical theft. So if you wish to converse, you'll have to put up with them, I'm afraid, even if you disagree with them.

Legality and morality do not equate. This is true. If a law tells me to perform an act that I find morally reprehensible, I will refuse peacefully. This is known as civil disobedience. If a law tells me that I cannot perform an act that breaks the law for personal gain, this is called a crime.
How about this, if you steal a physical item, there is still just one item, if you infringe copyright there are now 2 or more of the "items" in question. I can't really make it simpler than that.
avatar
GameRager: Example 1: I don't buy or download a game, they make 0 dollars off of me, and still have their game/IP.

Example 2: I download and don't buy the same game........they again make ZERO FUKKING DOLLARS off of me, and they still have their intellectual property/game.
Receiving something that you otherwise wouldn't have gotten for free is one of the points I think Runehamster was trying to make. Either you get a car or a copy of a game, you're still receiving something that shouldn't have been yours in the first place.

But the BIG difference is that a pirated copy does not directly hurt anyone. Sure, if the person who downloaded the game would have otherwise bought it, then that's a loss of a potential sale, which does equal a loss in profits. However, this is only a potential loss for the company (no loss, but also no gain). Their money isn't being removed from their wallets every time a game is downloaded the same way if a physical object was stolen (no gain, but a huge loss as well).

So I guess a pirated copy might be able to qualify as being stolen based on the fact that you now have something that you should not have obtained. Take without the owner's consent - that's the definition of stealing. But it's also not really stealing because the definition is only taking into account physical things, which behave very differently than digital things. That's what makes this a grey area I guess. Everyone can have a different opinion of what's what.
I have seen someone say that that is why we have DEMOS for.
The problem with DEMOS is that they are not the full product. Trying a DEMO in the Gaming industry is analog to having a promoter give you a chocolate cookie, you loving it, and then you buying the product, only to find out the only chocolate cookie was the first one, the rest of them being plain non sweet watered down cookies.

So we pirate, we consume the whole package (or most of it) until we FEEL we have gotten something from it, if we do not, then we do not pay, if we do, then we (or some of us) pay.
avatar
GameRager: Example 1: I don't buy or download a game, they make 0 dollars off of me, and still have their game/IP.

Example 2: I download and don't buy the same game........they again make ZERO FUKKING DOLLARS off of me, and they still have their intellectual property/game.
avatar
GoJays2025: Receiving something that you otherwise wouldn't have gotten for free is one of the points I think Runehamster was trying to make. Either you get a car or a copy of a game, you're still receiving something that shouldn't have been yours in the first place.

But the BIG difference is that a pirated copy does not directly hurt anyone. Sure, if the person who downloaded the game would have otherwise bought it, then that's a loss of a potential sale, which does equal a loss in profits. However, this is only a potential loss for the company (no loss, but also no gain). Their money isn't being removed from their wallets every time a game is downloaded the same way if a physical object was stolen (no gain, but a huge loss as well).

So I guess a pirated copy might be able to qualify as being stolen based on the fact that you now have something that you should not have obtained. Take without the owner's consent - that's the definition of stealing. But it's also not really stealing because the definition is only taking into account physical things, which behave very differently than digital things. That's what makes this a grey area I guess. Everyone can have a different opinion of what's what.
As I said (well, pretty much), I don't have a dog in the fight but one of the things I always get sick of hearing from the anti-piracy side is how much game development is. As soon as I hear that I always point out that it costs so much because they worry more about the asthetics of a game than they do the gameplay itself (which ties into the bugs in so many games now). Do they need to spend millions upon millions of dollars to make a new engine every game so tha leaves sway realisticly in the wind? Do they need to pay Hollywood actors millions of dollars to do 15 minutes of narration? Do any of those things make the game any more fun? No. All they do is add to the presentation and the cost of the games development and ultimately the price we pay for them.

Look at it this way. I'm pretty sure a game like Borderlands cost pennies on the dollar to make compared to Crysis. Sure Crysis was a beautiful game to look at but the game itself was just an average run of the mill FPS, honsetly the first time I saw it in action I thought it was another Far Cry game. Borderlands had a cartoony look that made it not only easier (and cheaper) to make, but gave it a personality that fit the game, easier for it to run on a variety of machines without major upgrades and the gameplay itself was just more fun in my opinion. I can'[t tell you how many times I've heard people tell me how great of a game Borderlands was before I played it and the number of people that said Crysis was beautiful but ho-hum in the gameplay department.

Maybe if the devs quit worrying about making game solely based on giving the owner a reason to brag about his computer specs to makie his e-peen bigger and worried more about making good, fun games they might not only save money in development but get some of those "potential sales" the are losing and have people actually want to buy their games.
Gentlemen, I didn't attack any of you personally. I don't have any personal stake in whether you pirate a game or not. I was pointing out an invalidity in the arguments I've heard for piracy. In my humble opinion, breaking a law is wrong when done for one's own entertainment, regardless of how silly the law might or might not be. I can see this opinion is not universal, and beyond the point of legality it is a matter of personal morals. You do not need to justify yourself to me, and I did not mean for any of you to take this personally. In regards to my being a troll, I have endeavored to speak reasonably and not attack anyone personally. If I failed in this, I crave the forgiveness of those I may have insulted.

On the other hand, threatening downreps for an opinion that, regardless of personal feelings, is entirely legal, is not particularly intimidating. I have been on GOG for a very long time, and I don't really take notice of reputation points myself.
It's healthy debate, in my view. Nobody here, except for GameRager right here accusing Runehamster of fanboyism, is making personal attacks.

By the way, In the interest of full disclosure, I have pirated games, and continue to. I'm trying to curb my downloading of titles as much as possible with varying degrees of success. I'm pretty much down to 0 piracy now, though sometimes I'm pretty tempted. But I feel it is important to reconcile my actions with my moral position.
Anyway, a few of observations from me:

The assertion that a game demo isn't a good representation of the game experience doesn't stand up in my view. What matters is that you are able to experience the core game mechanic, such that you can explore its entertainment value. You are given this. It is more than enough to work out whether a game is inherently fun or not. Extra features that aren't part of the bulk of the game, different permutations of gameplay etc. do not serve to help you work this out.
Further, how long are you going to play this game? If your idea is that you need the full feature set to work out whether you want a game or not - to experience it in its entirety, then are you going to finish it? After you've explored every nook and cranny of the game, what incentive is there for you then to buy it? Who has the kind of self-discipline to stop playing after they've realised the game is fun? Granted, they may do so if it is a stultifying experience, but then they're not going to buy it anyway. To be honest, it need not be the "entire" game, anyway, as most people don't play all the way through purchased copies of games.


I would posit that it actually *is* an immoral act to pirate a game, even though it doesn't immediately disadvantage the vendor/publisher/developer.
First of all, I think that the violation of the contract between the parties actually is immoral. The terms on which someone is willing to offer their IP - what they spent a great deal of hard work in creating - is up to them to set. If you don't like these terms, if the price is too high, then you are excluded from the contract. Nothing is forcing you to enter it. This is the way society works.
In my mind, the cracker/pirate who offers the IP (which they do not own) on different, less stringent terms, is violating the owner's right to offer the product as they see fit. Similarly, by participating in these "clandestine" alternative routes of acquisition is to support this violation, as the original owner has not consented to allow you to use their property. In this way, the consumer undermines the right of the developer to offer goods/services as they wish to. (hence DRM)
These kinds of agreements, and agreeing to the limitations that go with them is central to our society economically and culturally/socially, if you ask me.


My next point is largely supposition, I suppose, but I think it's reasonable - I think I've observed these tendencies in myself.
Game piracy is insidious in its temptation. Even if you begin to pirate with the best of intentions, or if the games you pirate you genuinely can't afford, it leads you to the kind which everyone seems to agree is bad. The kind which sacrifices sales for developers. Sure, it is true that most people can't afford large game libraries. Putting aside the point that if they can't afford them, then they have no right to them (which has been covered well by Runehamster), the act of downloading these games eases a person into piracy. It becomes easy, convenient, lacking in the obstacles of DRM, the physical or virtual trip to a vendor, the necessity of handling credit card numbers, cash etc. It is only natural given this convenience that a person will eventually forgo the difficulty of jumping through these hoops even if they could do so. Perhaps the person hasn't examined their calculus in this matter. Maybe if it were brought to their attention that they could afford the product, they might reluctantly agree.
More likely, I think, is that they would not like their comfort and moral incompatibilities pointed out and flood message boards, arguing about the inhumanity of the anti-piracy measures and positions people take. Nonetheless, I see that it is possible for even a well-meaning individual to succumb to the most deleterious form of piracy, and in my mind, that is enough to try to combat it in itself. If the price is a few less games played by individuals, then that is worth it.

The idea that people must play the very best and greatest games to be spared their miserable lives does not float with me. If they can afford the hardware to play the very latest games, then they can afford the games themselves. That is beyond equivocation, as far as I'm concerned.
In any case, even if it is not, there are great number of freeware, old, handheld or cheap games out there which don't require much hardware or cash to play, GoG is testament to that fact. I have seen homeless men with laptop computers. Even the most destitute person can find some game to play, probably games that are more fun than your average AAA shooter that is pirated these days. And anyway, there are other modes of entertainment - some more fulfilling than videogaming - available to people. Things which don't cost money. It is not a case of playing games on your computer or suicide.


To be honest, the whole discussion about sales is kind of a red herring anyway. It's completely uncontroversial that piracy has lost game companies money. We've seen a huge shrinkage in the PC games market as a result of the ease of piracy on the system, with escalating arms wars between developer DRM tech and hackers and their hacks.
It is to avoid the point to say that "well, some people wouldn't have bought it anyway, so there are no sales lost". It is sophistry. The fact is there are such people, they are in the main, and they are sufficient reason to take action to stop piracy. For developers, and for society at large. It happens that there is evidence for this loss of sales, but even if there weren't, it's a reasonable thing to infer it. It's a simple matter of economics. For a rational actor in an economy, if they have an expensive, inconvenient option and a free, convenient option, some number of people are going to choose the latter one (ignoring morality, or trying to explain it away with bogus justifications) even if they can afford the former!
To me this is elementary! Simple! I fail to see why people so often ignore this point, and call developers draconian for trying to defend against it.
I notice that there is much less vitriol amongst the advocates for the free dissemination of IP for the console companies like Nintendo who try to act against modchips or flashcards. Apparently if piracy is inconvenient, then it's more wrong. I think Runehamster's point about "might is right" has a bearing here, but I'll leave it be for fear of becoming glib.

As a result of these forces at work, it's little wonder that developers have developed DRM. It also necessarily has to be invasive these days to stand any chance of working. The point that it doesn't work, therefore they shouldn't do it doesn't stand up. It's their responsibility as companies to try to defend the dividends of their shareholders. In any event, they have a right, and if you don't like it, don't buy the game.
It's too easy to just blame the man. To call the big bad developers evil rather than to examine our own comfortable suppositions, or to condemn the pirates around and within us.
It requires doublethink to believe that theft of information is different from the theft of physical materials in any moral sense. Information matters too, and I vote we respect the rights of developers instead of trying to justify our own theft.


I don't think it's difficult to work out that piracy is dangerous. Allow me to present a simple thought experiment. Say piracy becomes decriminalised, and loses any stigma. What happens? Everyone simply downloads the games for free, and developers' revenue dries up. They stop making games. I think if we allow piracy to become too comfortable, we're in danger of going some way down this path. It leads to a future of subscription models and advertisement breaks during games, and it's not a future I relish.
Games companies rely on sales for their survival and for the continuing development of new titles. I think it's not only their legal, but their moral right to attempt to protect this.
avatar
Runehamster: In my humble opinion, breaking a law is wrong when done for one's own entertainment, regardless of how silly the law might or might not be.
No it's fine, I don't think you were really attacking anyone on a personal level. I agree with some stuff you've said, but it's just a little pointless arguing over morals since people all have different beliefs.

Let me ask you though based on the above quote. Is it fine to go 65km/h on a 60km/h road if you're going to see a movie? It's not legal; you're doing it as a means for obtaining entertainment... yet, most people won't think this is unreasonable, would they?
avatar
Runehamster: Gentlemen, I didn't attack any of you personally. I don't have any personal stake in whether you pirate a game or not. I was pointing out an invalidity in the arguments I've heard for piracy. In my humble opinion, breaking a law is wrong when done for one's own entertainment, regardless of how silly the law might or might not be. I can see this opinion is not universal, and beyond the point of legality it is a matter of personal morals. You do not need to justify yourself to me, and I did not mean for any of you to take this personally. In regards to my being a troll, I have endeavored to speak reasonably and not attack anyone personally. If I failed in this, I crave the forgiveness of those I may have insulted.

On the other hand, threatening downreps for an opinion that, regardless of personal feelings, is entirely legal, is not particularly intimidating. I have been on GOG for a very long time, and I don't really take notice of reputation points myself.
I hope you didn't take the Youtube video I posted as an attack on your stance. It's just that honestly as I said in the post, while reading your comments I heard that song playing in my head. (I think it has to do with seeing it so much in discussions like this on the Escapist lol)

Also, my last post wasn't about anyone in particular as it was just one of the ways it seems that companies could try to combat piracy. The sad thing is, we have to remind the developers and publishers that the best way to sell more product is to have a good product in the first place.

If you took my posts as an attack or criticism towards you, I apologize as that was not my intent at all.
avatar
RowdyRodimus: As I said (well, pretty much), I don't have a dog in the fight but one of the things I always get sick of hearing from the anti-piracy side is how much game development is. *snip*
avatar
GameRager: -on the same issue-
That developers should make games really cheaply so that people can pirate the game without the developer going bust is not only a concession that piracy is a real problem, but bullshit on its own merits.

These qualities - graphics, sound, cross-platform support are all things that the gamers demand. Moreover, they are what makes up a good game. I know, however shallow it may seem, that I enjoy games with good graphics more than games with bad graphics, given equivalent gameplay. It helps to get me into the game, and eyecandy is enjoyable by itself.
Are you really suggesting that game developers should just make shit games?

Also, I think you're under-estimating the amount of time developers spend actually building gameplay. Most modern titles use existing middleware engines for actual graphics tech, and while there are a large number of artists on a dev team, there are also a ton of coders, beavering away on game code, implementing mechanics, even if they aren't inspired mechanics. That's a problem with design, but modern games are pretty complex - the expectation is that a certain number of man hours have been spend coding away at AI or whatever. It's a pretty high hour count.

The "big fat executives" bonus is almost laughable enough to dismiss without proof (as it was asserted without proof). Still, I have to point out that that management is a core part of delivering a game (the same with advertisement and so forth) and it's only people like John Riccietello whose companies make billions and billions of dollars who really pull large bonuses and salaries etc.



I kind of wanted to respond to the speed limit question, but it's not posed to me, so I'll wait for it to be answered first.
Post edited October 28, 2010 by Tonjevic