It's healthy debate, in my view. Nobody here, except for GameRager right here accusing Runehamster of fanboyism, is making personal attacks.
By the way, In the interest of full disclosure, I have pirated games, and continue to. I'm trying to curb my downloading of titles as much as possible with varying degrees of success. I'm pretty much down to 0 piracy now, though sometimes I'm pretty tempted. But I feel it is important to reconcile my actions with my moral position.
Anyway, a few of observations from me:
The assertion that a game demo isn't a good representation of the game experience doesn't stand up in my view. What matters is that you are able to experience the core game mechanic, such that you can explore its entertainment value. You are given this. It is more than enough to work out whether a game is inherently fun or not. Extra features that aren't part of the bulk of the game, different permutations of gameplay etc. do not serve to help you work this out.
Further, how long are you going to play this game? If your idea is that you need the full feature set to work out whether you want a game or not - to experience it in its entirety, then are you going to finish it? After you've explored every nook and cranny of the game, what incentive is there for you then to buy it? Who has the kind of self-discipline to stop playing after they've realised the game is fun? Granted, they may do so if it is a stultifying experience, but then they're not going to buy it anyway. To be honest, it need not be the "entire" game, anyway, as most people don't play all the way through purchased copies of games.
I would posit that it actually *is* an immoral act to pirate a game, even though it doesn't immediately disadvantage the vendor/publisher/developer.
First of all, I think that the violation of the contract between the parties actually is immoral. The terms on which someone is willing to offer their IP - what they spent a great deal of hard work in creating - is up to them to set. If you don't like these terms, if the price is too high, then you are excluded from the contract. Nothing is forcing you to enter it. This is the way society works.
In my mind, the cracker/pirate who offers the IP (which they do not own) on different, less stringent terms, is violating the owner's right to offer the product as they see fit. Similarly, by participating in these "clandestine" alternative routes of acquisition is to support this violation, as the original owner has not consented to allow you to use their property. In this way, the consumer undermines the right of the developer to offer goods/services as they wish to. (hence DRM)
These kinds of agreements, and agreeing to the limitations that go with them is central to our society economically and culturally/socially, if you ask me.
My next point is largely supposition, I suppose, but I think it's reasonable - I think I've observed these tendencies in myself.
Game piracy is insidious in its temptation. Even if you begin to pirate with the best of intentions, or if the games you pirate you genuinely can't afford, it leads you to the kind which everyone seems to agree is bad. The kind which sacrifices sales for developers. Sure, it is true that most people can't afford large game libraries. Putting aside the point that if they can't afford them, then they have no right to them (which has been covered well by Runehamster), the act of downloading these games eases a person into piracy. It becomes easy, convenient, lacking in the obstacles of DRM, the physical or virtual trip to a vendor, the necessity of handling credit card numbers, cash etc. It is only natural given this convenience that a person will eventually forgo the difficulty of jumping through these hoops even if they could do so. Perhaps the person hasn't examined their calculus in this matter. Maybe if it were brought to their attention that they could afford the product, they might reluctantly agree.
More likely, I think, is that they would not like their comfort and moral incompatibilities pointed out and flood message boards, arguing about the inhumanity of the anti-piracy measures and positions people take. Nonetheless, I see that it is possible for even a well-meaning individual to succumb to the most deleterious form of piracy, and in my mind, that is enough to try to combat it in itself. If the price is a few less games played by individuals, then that is worth it.
The idea that people must play the very best and greatest games to be spared their miserable lives does not float with me. If they can afford the hardware to play the very latest games, then they can afford the games themselves. That is beyond equivocation, as far as I'm concerned.
In any case, even if it is not, there are great number of freeware, old, handheld or cheap games out there which don't require much hardware or cash to play, GoG is testament to that fact. I have seen homeless men with laptop computers. Even the most destitute person can find some game to play, probably games that are more fun than your average AAA shooter that is pirated these days. And anyway, there are other modes of entertainment - some more fulfilling than videogaming - available to people. Things which don't cost money. It is not a case of playing games on your computer or suicide.
To be honest, the whole discussion about sales is kind of a red herring anyway. It's completely uncontroversial that piracy has lost game companies money. We've seen a huge shrinkage in the PC games market as a result of the ease of piracy on the system, with escalating arms wars between developer DRM tech and hackers and their hacks.
It is to avoid the point to say that "well, some people wouldn't have bought it anyway, so there are no sales lost". It is sophistry. The fact is there are such people, they are in the main, and they are sufficient reason to take action to stop piracy. For developers, and for society at large. It happens that there is evidence for this loss of sales, but even if there weren't, it's a reasonable thing to infer it. It's a simple matter of economics. For a rational actor in an economy, if they have an expensive, inconvenient option and a free, convenient option, some number of people are going to choose the latter one (ignoring morality, or trying to explain it away with bogus justifications) even if they can afford the former!
To me this is elementary! Simple! I fail to see why people so often ignore this point, and call developers draconian for trying to defend against it.
I notice that there is much less vitriol amongst the advocates for the free dissemination of IP for the console companies like Nintendo who try to act against modchips or flashcards. Apparently if piracy is inconvenient, then it's more wrong. I think Runehamster's point about "might is right" has a bearing here, but I'll leave it be for fear of becoming glib.
As a result of these forces at work, it's little wonder that developers have developed DRM. It also necessarily has to be invasive these days to stand any chance of working. The point that it doesn't work, therefore they shouldn't do it doesn't stand up. It's their responsibility as companies to try to defend the dividends of their shareholders. In any event, they have a right, and if you don't like it, don't buy the game.
It's too easy to just blame the man. To call the big bad developers evil rather than to examine our own comfortable suppositions, or to condemn the pirates around and within us.
It requires doublethink to believe that theft of information is different from the theft of physical materials in any moral sense. Information matters too, and I vote we respect the rights of developers instead of trying to justify our own theft.
I don't think it's difficult to work out that piracy is dangerous. Allow me to present a simple thought experiment. Say piracy becomes decriminalised, and loses any stigma. What happens? Everyone simply downloads the games for free, and developers' revenue dries up. They stop making games. I think if we allow piracy to become too comfortable, we're in danger of going some way down this path. It leads to a future of subscription models and advertisement breaks during games, and it's not a future I relish.
Games companies rely on sales for their survival and for the continuing development of new titles. I think it's not only their legal, but their moral right to attempt to protect this.